Sometimes, I think that Twilight and Harry Potter are tied. They are both good stories, right? Recently, I have been doing a lot of thinking and I think I like Twilight better. Below, I am going to give you 5 reasons Twilight is better than Harry Potter, in my opinion, because I know it is all a matter of preference.
5. There’s No Magic School
Yeah, this is a pretty good reason as to why Twilight is better than Harry Potter. Each year, they didn’t have to go to a school to learn their powers. They already knew their powers. However, a school for vampires would have added a cool twist to it, don’t you think?
***
One of the charms of the Twilight universe is the innate abilities that vampires and werewolves possess. They hone their skills through personal experience and mentorship rather than formal education. It brings a sense of realism and relatability, as everyone goes through the journey of self-discovery. Imagine having your vampire mentor casually drop hints on how to better control your thirst for blood while you're out shopping, instead of sitting in a classroom. Now, that's a fresh take on supernatural adolescence that feels uniquely Twilight!
4. Edward Wasn’t a Dork
Yeah, sometimes, dorks are cute. However, Harry was a bit too dorky and I can’t see why girls even liked him. I do like the stories, but I don’t really did the movies as much. However, I like both the books and movies when it comes to Twilight.
***
Edward Cullen, with his enigmatic allure and vampire mystique, offered a stark contrast to the often awkward and self-deprecating Harry Potter. His confident yet tormented personality exuded a dark charm that many found irresistible. He was never clumsy with his words or actions, which made him appear suave and sophisticated. In essence, Edward epitomized the classic brooding hero, which is a trope that never fails to capture hearts. Coupled with his supernatural appeal and protective nature, it's no wonder he became the epitome of teenage fantasy and a romantic figure that didn't need to resort to dorkiness to be adored.
Frequently asked questions
Not really! Harry Potter's world is full of magical creatures, but vampires aren't a big part of the story. Twilight, on the other hand, is all about vampires and their secretive, glamorous lives.
It's all about personal taste! Some people prefer the romance and intense emotions in Twilight, while others enjoy the adventure and magical world in Harry Potter. It's like choosing between chocolate and vanilla ice cream—both are great, but different people have their favorites!
If you love Harry Potter, you might enjoy books like 'Percy Jackson & The Olympians' for more magical adventures. For Twilight fans, 'The Vampire Diaries' offers another take on vampire romance. There are so many wonderful books out there!
That's up for debate! Twilight fans love the central love story between Bella and Edward because it's dramatic and full of tension. Harry Potter has love stories too, but they play a smaller role compared to the main adventure.
Some people believe the magic and fantasy elements might be inappropriate or conflict with personal beliefs, but others argue it's a great way to spark imagination and encourage reading. It's a hot topic for sure!
3. Love Story
Harry Potter is not a love story and Twilight is. Therefore, in my opinion, I believe this would make Twilight better than Harry Potter.
***
The emotional core of Twilight hinges on the intense romance between Bella and Edward. Their relationship is fraught with drama, passion, and the thrill of forbidden love, which resonates with many readers, particularly those who relish the escapism of a good romance story. It's the kind of love affair that has fans fiercely invested in the characters' fates, debating Team Edward or Team Jacob, and swooning over their favorite moments. While Harry Potter does feature romantic subplots, they're just that—subplots, rather than the driving force of the narrative. Twilight, on the other hand, places love front and center, capturing the hearts of its audience in a way that's uniquely its own.
2. Twilight Has Vampires
I like Twilight because it has vampires in it. I think this helps to make it better than Harry Potter, don’t you? Even just a little?
***
Vampires add a sense of forbidden allure and mystery that is undeniably attractive. Their timeless charm and complex nature give a romantic edge that's hard to find in other supernatural tales. And let's be honest, the vampire-human love story between Edward and Bella is a magnetic narrative that pulls at the heartstrings. Twilight showcases the dilemmas and passions that come with such an enthralling bond, making it positively irresistible! The idea of immortality mixed with romance is a combination that gives the saga an added level of depth and excitement, perfectly fueling the addiction to the series.
1. Better Story
Personally, I think Twilight was better than Harry Potter because it had a better story to it. Twilight always had my attention and even though I liked Harry Potter, I dealt with moments of boredom.
Those are 5 reasons Twilight is better than Harry Potter. I know there are some pretty big Harry Potter fans out there that will swamp my blog with saying Harry Potter is better, but that’s fine. Nothing wrong with Harry Potter. So, are you a Harry Potter fan or Twilight? Or Both?
Top Photo Credit: donna_makes_cakes
Comments
Anonymous: Actually, Harry Potter does have vampires. They might not be front and center, but they're there.
Isabel: Ahem. Darling this was painful to read. Point A) Harry Potter is not a love story. WTF? There is so much love in Harry Potter. Romantic love, of course, for example Harry and Ginny. Parental love, a HUGE theme in the books- how Lily dies to save her son. Platonic (friendly) love, between Harry and his friends Ron and Hermione and everyone. The list goes on. The "love" in Twilight is dull romantic love, as in "I can't live without you- without you I'm going to die." Two dimensional. Point B) Best Story. I almost died here. Best story? Ha. The storyline in Twilight is predictable and entirely a ROMANCE. Harry Potter is an action story, adventure, romance, so much more. The plot twists and turns with all kinds of adventures and details. There are so many details in HP, so many things to dwell on, so many intricacies of the writing... in Twilight, its "Is she going to pick Jacob or Edward?" and that's it. (:
Noir: Dear Random Idiot. Oh my god... this made me laugh my arse off... A school for vampires... would be a normal school except with a little bit of blood lust, so FUCKING BORING. HARRY POTTER IS A LOVE STORY YOU MORON! Have you even read the books? I have read both series' honestly twilight I barely made it through the first book let alone the other 3, the name of the child Edward and Bella have... OMG how stupid... please... we know edward may be your "Mr. Perfect" but I rather not have a creepy stalker guy. I rather have that cute little nerd. Please... learn to choose better literature... because Twilight is like reading something written by a eleven year old. Hope this has enlightened you, to what a moron you are and why you should have a brain transport as soon as possible.
hedwig: what bullshitt! twilight better than harry potter! wat r u! retarded or something! harry potter is a lifestyle!! jacob falling for bella...then he falls for bella's kid!! ew..thats gross! nd shape shifter! really! ha! my ass! complete rubbish!
Hanalei: P.S. If one cared to do further researched they would realize that there are vampires in the Wizarding World. Harry simply does not encounter one, thankfully none of those sparkly bastards who contradict vampire lore.
dabeshu: Harry potter is for kids but twilight is for anyone from the age when they start reading up till the oldest person living Twilight is very cool. I'm a guy, and I felt the movie was different. It wasn't bad when I was watching it, it just felt like something new and exciting when I watched the movie. Whereas harry potter wasnt /bad/, but it was made for children. I'm also not really into 'magic'. Characters. I believe this speaks for itself. Can I get a hey-yo? Although harry potter is such a nerd, he is mostly a child in the movies and I'm not a gay pedophile I'm just gay. Edward > HP Finally I don't care what anyone says, Steven 'King' or not, I like to read Stephanie Meyer's words better than I do like to read 'Just Kidding' Wraling. That's what I like to call her coz her writing is a joke. Can I get two hey-yo's at a time? Thank you.
Anonymous: I Suppose you think Twilight is better than Harry Potter because there is a 'love story'. If Bella really Loved Edward would she make out with Jacob? i think not. When Ron left Hermione she continued her search for Horcruxes and helped Harry defeat the most evil wizard of all time. when Edward left Bella she became depressed and then jumped of a cliff. And Harry Potter DOES have love stories and they are a lot more heart-warming than a silly 18 year old girl trying to get her vampire hisband to fuck her. Severus Snape loved Lily Evans-Potter a HELL of a lot more than Bella will ever love Edward. Harry Potter is about finding inner strength. It's about realising that Love is the most powerful thing in this world and that there are things in this world much worse than death. Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend. In Conclusion, The only good thing you can do with Twilight books is wipe your arse.
:
EST 2005
Evolve. Empower. Elevate.
- Creators on the platform
- 3,000+
- Total social reach
- 12M+
- Features published
- 100K+
New Earn badges & level up while you read
Create your profile. Earn badges. Level up your reading.
Join Allwomenstalk to track your streaks, collect badges, and earn XP for the things you already do—reading, sharing, and taking quizzes.
- 🔥Daily streaks with gentle boosts for 3, 7, and 30 days.
- 🏅Collect badges like Reader I–III, Socialite, and Quiz Ace.
- ⚡️Earn XP for reads, deep reads, likes, comments, and shares.
It’s free. Takes 30 seconds. Already have an account? Sign in.
Feedback Junction
Where Thoughts and Opinions Converge